Singal-Minded

Singal-Minded

I Wish The People Trying To Build A Better World Would Stop Endlessly Obsessing Over Linguistic Minutiae

There’s almost no chance this stuff matters much, overhyped studies notwithstanding

Jesse Singal
Oct 10, 2022
∙ Paid

It’s an exciting tweet:

X avatar for @mdawriter
melinda d. anderson@mdawriter
New study confirms that the term “achievement gap” fosters a negative view of Black students—researchers found it triggers racist stereotypes and causes a lower sense of urgency than when issue is presented as “ending inequality in educational outcomes.”
edworkingpapers.com
Replicating and Extending Effects of “Achievement Gap” Discourse
9:42 PM · Oct 4, 2022

352 Reposts · 924 Likes

The link points to a working paper (that is, not yet peer-reviewed) by David M. Quinn and Tara-Marie Desruisseaux of the University of Southern California, published by the Annenberg Institute at Brown University.

Quinn and Desruisseaux used an online sample of teachers to generate their result. “We randomly assigned teachers to one of two versions of a survey item, asking some to rate how much of a priority they felt it was to ‘close the (Black/White) achievement gap,’ and others to rate the conceptually synonymous ‘ending (Black/White) inequality in educational outcomes.’”

The respondents answered the following questions. Below is how it looked with the “achievement gap” language, but others were asked to answer the same questions regarding “inequality in educational outcomes.”

My first observation is that for this study to tell us anything, it’s really, really important for these actually to be near-synonymous terms, and I’m not sure they are.

User's avatar

Continue reading this post for free, courtesy of Jesse Singal.

Or purchase a paid subscription.
© 2026 Jesse Singal · Privacy ∙ Terms ∙ Collection notice
Start your SubstackGet the app
Substack is the home for great culture